In the past few years, the Nike corporation has offered a microcosm of the issues surrounding consumerism and the global free market economy. Nike, like many other corporations from the economized world, has been criticized for exploiting laborers in manufacturing plants relocated to less economized societies. This exploitation has appeared grosser in that they are producing luxury products for over consumptive economized societies and disproportionally reward their star endorsers with lucrative contracts.1 The mounting criticism and campaigns against Nike, however, have not had much impact on a key part of their market, urban African-America. Poor African Americans understandably have some difficulty extending concern for abuses of workers overseas when the injustices they face in their own country are similarly acute. In this last section, I would like to apply paticca samuppada to the consumer experience surrounding sports apparel like Nike and Reebok. In doing so, I hope to expose some further concerns about the conduct of corporations like Nike who base themselves on the over consumption of luxury goods. Further, I believe paticca samuppada will help reveal the debilitating mentalities engendered by such consumption which more deeply imprison those in economized societies in a system of economic injustice. Let us now look at what paticca samuppada within this consumerism perspective can reveal about a typical young man from an American ghetto raised on "Hoop Dreams".2
1. IGNORANCE (avijja)
American ghettos represent the bottom of the pyramid of success
in the American consumer dream. Due to poor education facilities
and little access to the levers of power which could raise oneself
up, the consumer lifestyle represents a banquet feast of which
only scraps can be eaten. Like rural areas in the more vernacular
South, these are forgotten deserts of the consumer dream where
people are fed images of the world of success, power and wealth
through the television and other forms of media.
A young man, often from a family with no father, will have very
few direct role models who embody such power, success and wealth.
These models are found in the images of the "outside world",
outside of his part of town where no one goes if they don't have
to. Such separation from the real complexities of power, success
and wealth may create the image of a stable (nicca) and
satisfying (sukha) way of life. As someone can get intoxicated
with promises of heaven, so can one get intoxicated with the images
of ease and well being in wealth. Such a situation also further
imbeds the sensibility of "self" (atta) in that
power is outside oneself, not of this neighborhood or this way
of life and very far away. To achieve such power, access to the
"outside world" must be gained.
MENTAL STEWING
2. CONCOCTING (sankhara)
3. CONSCIOUSNESS (vinnana)
4. MIND-BODY (namarupa)
5. SENSE EXPERIENCE (salayatana)
Such an environment where so many are powerless helps to further harden the view of power being "out there". In this young man, a stewing begins in which the mind becomes attuned to displays of power. This stewing will deepen, become more complex and ultimately feed back into itself to concoct further. As the concocted mind grows, the young man will have a few different kinds of power to discern from. In his own neighborhood, there will be the power of the drug dealers and the gangsters. With money and weapons, they offer the quickest but most dangerous way to material power. Other local forms of power may be found in a dedicated local teacher or a single mother taking care of a family herself. With selflessness, dedication and hard work, they offer the truer forms of internal power, but receive little or no reward in terms of wealth. The other forms of power are most likely to come from the "outside world" through its window, the television.
Competitive sports is one of the most compelling forms of consumption.
It embodies all the ideals of the consumer world: physical form,
competition, and wealth. To a young boy from the ghetto, it embodies
one of the few passage ways to the outside world of power, wealth
and fame. So as a young, still idealistic boy, the path of professional
sports can become that focus for gaining power, success and wealth.
The young man knows drug dealing is considered bad and is also
dangerous, and he also knows that the power of those working to
survive in the ghetto has no glamour and very few rewards. With
the most common form of advancement in education cut off in poor
schooling or skewed out of perspective through the distractions
of image and style, such a focus on athletic power seems like
a good course. Such begins the narrowing of the mind into a limiting
framework for encountering the world. For the young middle or
upper class boy, this is an unfortunate consequence which can
stunt his growth. For the young ghetto boy, it is survival, the
way he must begin to frame his reality if he is to try to make
it out of his debilitating environment.
From such a process, the young boy's mind begins the bifurcation
process developing dualistic sensibilities between mind and body
and "self" and "other" in terms of athletic
power. There is now a distinct athletic being arising in the young
boy. With such mental attuning, the senses become primed to make
contact with aspects of athletic power and success. Sight Experience
will probably become the more prominent Sense Experience to concoct
Full Contact. The Mental Experience concocted from the senses
is also especially important here since it links more directly
to the more existential power aspect of athletics.
6. FULL CONTACT (phassa)
Still living in the consumer desert of the ghetto, the young man's
most frequent and common form of contact is with media, television
and advertising in particular. This is perhaps the most dangerous
aspect of his environment. The ghetto is very limited in its possibilities
for young men to see the full spectrum of experience offered in
the "outside world". Advertising and television offer
carefully molded images which feature snapshots and sound bites
of the real world of competitive athletics. In this way, our young
man comes into daily contact with the ultimate sports success
image, Michael Jordan: winner, handsome, well-spoken, endorsements,
a good family, fantastic physical gifts. This man is too good
to be true, and advertising and his own image machine (agent)
make sure that this cannot be doubted. As an athlete, he is a
remarkable specimen. As a symbol of power, success and wealth
for the young man living in the ghetto, he is the ultimate model
of an African American who has "made it" in the "outside
world".3
As such there are myriad forms of contact that the young man can
experience: posters, TV commercials, food products, T-shirts,
jerseys and, of course, the thing that got it all going - Air
Jordans - his personalized line of basketball shoes. Even for
one who is not a basketball fan, these shoes seem to have an incredible
aura and ability to create Full Contact through Sight Experience.
One Saturday while visiting a downtown mall, the young boy stumbles
upon Foot Locker, the national (now international) sports apparel
chain, and catches sight of the latest Air Jordans in the store
front display. With Mental Stewing concocted, there arise
the core perceptions (sanna) at this Full Contact. Beauty
(supa) and pleasure (sukha) arise with the fine
craftsmanship and unique characteristics of the shoes. Most certainly,
perception of "self" (atta) arises as the shoes
carry the essence and aura of Michael Jordan himself. With this
"self" perceived, there will be a stronger perception
of the young boy's own "self" which forms a contrast
to heighten this Full Contact (like hot heightens cold).
7. FEELING (vedana)
Feeling arises mostly certainly in a positive way with the Air
Jordans and other associated apparel and products. In contrast,
the whole other world of negativity gets lumped into the shoes
with no name, no image and no attractive athlete endorsing them.
Thirdly, the ladies tennis shoes on sale are barely noticed in
neither-pleasant-nor-painful Feeling.
These Feelings for athletic power give rise to more detailed perceptions
(sanna) about the right kind of athletic power. It's not
badminton. It's not the selfless team player sacrificing his own
glory for the win. It's the basketball player, the baseball player.
The big sports star who makes the big money. It's the dunker,
the home run hitter, the good looking guy with the big contract.
As important as it is to win, it is also as important to have
the right image which includes the shoe contract, the endorsement
packages, the famous actress girlfriend, the celebrity golf tournament
appearances, etc. The mind here starts to divide in a myriad of
ways towards Craving and Clinging where the fine tuning of what
it is the "self" wants will take place.
8. CRAVING (tanha)
The comparing of the positive feelings concocted through the Air
Jordans and the negative ones concocted through his own shoes
condition the young boy to Crave the Air Jordans (Sense Craving).
On a deeper level, the young boy begins to Crave the state of
being of Jordan and other professional athletes (Craving for Being).
Craving for Non-Being will also arise in reflection upon his own
situation which is so far from this world of pleasure that he
is getting just a taste of now at the sports store. Here these
comparisons and identifications are taking place as the mind becomes
more dualistic. The boy sees himself (Craving for Non-Being) and
what he wants to have in the shoes (Sense Craving) and be in Jordan
(Craving for Being). The seemingly impossible gap of space and
time between his state and Jordan's creates an almost paralyzing
feel of lack and alienation. The shoes, however, as a concrete
manifestation of this Craving for Being represent an attainable
intermediate step in the dream (or do they?). Pinned to the storefront
glass gazing at the shoes, the neither-pleasurable-nor-painful
book store next door is barely noticed, and one door towards a
real step to the dream remains closed.
9. CLINGING (upadana )
From the three levels of Craving, Clinging is concocted.
1) From the Craving of the Air Jordans (Sense Craving), the boy
now cannot take his eyes off them. He becomes totally preoccupied
with them, unwilling to even look at shoes of equal quality
but at a more affordable price. (Sense Clinging).
2) On a deeper level, his Craving for Being with Jordan and professional
athletes begins to concoct into a deeper belief that, "Yes,
this is the life! Being an NBA star is the ultimate! This will
be my dream!" (Attitude Clinging).
3) With the arising of these beliefs, he not only begins to Cling
ever more strongly to the shoes as one of the means to this way
of life, but he also begins to Cling to all the ideas he has for
realizing this belief, "I'll have to skip study period to
work on my jumper this afternoon" (Behavioral Clinging).
4) With all these hardened images of "self" on top of
his initial identifications, a shoes-wanting, sports loving, power
craving guy is truly emerging (Self Clinging). This hardening
of "self" image further blocks out questions and perspectives
that could be raised like,"Why not buy the cheaper shoes
and use the extra on that Cornell West book."; "I read
another story about a star who got addicted to cocaine and beat
his wife. Maybe this life isn't so easy after all?"; and
"If I don't get a real degree, what will I do after I retire?
Run a liquor store?"
MATURATION OF THE "SELF"
10. EXISTENCE (bhava)
11. BIRTH (jati)
With initial identifications made in Craving and the emergence of his athletic "I" in Clinging, the boy's "self" is maturing. He obsesses about the shoes, "I'm going to get them!"; he dwells more deeply on his dream, "Nobody's gonna stop me"; and he plans more thoroughly his path, "First, I got the shoes, then make the team, then the scholarship to Carolina - no, Michigan, yeah, two years, then lottery pick and long term 3 figure contract after two!"4 From such a process arises solidified identifications of the boy as great athlete "self" with environments and situations to which he will belong and which will realize the dream: initially, Foot Locker, the store of dreams, then the high school team, the four year university of which he already has a short list, and, of course, the NBA franchise he will play for, "Chicago? naw too hard to follow Michael"; "Miami, no Riley'll kill me"; "L.A., yeah, L.A., running with Shaq and Kobe!" and of course the non-identifications "What if I'm drafted by Utah? Salt Lake City!!??", "If I don't go Division I-A, I'm dead!"5 These identifications are forming an ideal future "self" based on the objectified and deluded desires of Craving and Clinging. As such, a vision of "self" is being born which will only further frustrate the reality of the present "self" thus only deepening the sense of lack which the boy is trying to build over.
The young boy at age 12 has made the trip to the mall that will
change his life. He leaves with no Air Jordans but with a new
born babe, a "self" brewed from the depravities of his
environment (Dukkha) and the understandable Ignorance with how
to get out of it. The concocted mind is matured and in place to
concoct myriad new forms of attachment. Nurtured by the Craving
and Clinging to sports "images" and poised to activate
through identifications, this "self" is taking on its
own energy for growth and survival.
12. AGING & DYING (jaramarana)
The boy's immediate experience with Aging & Dying is in depression
in his inability to buy the shoes that day. As soon as he leaves
the store, the magic is gone. Jordan and his shoes stay in the
store, and he is left with the same "self" that came
in the store. The excitement that gets left in the store will
probably turn into boredom with the activities of school and life
which are not connected in some way to this sports excitement.
He may also experience fear when he thinks about how difficult
and treacherous the road is to his dream as a professional athlete.
If causes and conditions are kind to him, he may indeed see the
mature development of a sports athlete "self". What
probably will happen is that this "self" will get mixed
with his other concocted selves and eventually derail the project.
The most perverse, yet not uncommon, scenario is the "self"
becomes stuck in the images of Clinging while losing what it really
takes to achieve. For someone in his situation, being hooked to
material forms and styles with no skills or substance to back
them up are good qualifications for becoming a drug dealer.
THE DEEPER INJUSTICES OF STRUCTURAL
CONSUMER PATICCA SAMUPPADA
The full ramifications of this birth are not readily apparent
from the personal model. "So a kid goes to the mall, falls
in love with Michael Jordan and wants to become a sports hero
- what's wrong with that?", we might ask. Surely, it would
seem nothing. The same thing probably happened to Michael Jordan
many years ago when he went into a store, saw a picture of Dr.
J and bought his first pair of Converse. The key point of this
case study is the way that this initial mental paticca samuppada
is recreated in young boys all over the country. On a mass level
it feeds the building and maintenance of structures all of which
are infused with the Ignorance and Craving for money and the consumer
culture that marks the highest levels of sport. The ramifications
of these structures built on greed can be shrugged off by those
with the financial means to get off in tact through paying for
school if a scholarship is not offered or getting a different,
respectable job since their schooling was adequate. As we have
seen, however, these kinds of consumer fed dreams are the bulwarks
of a system of economic injustice which bites most deeply at the
bottom of the pyramid.
CRAVING (tanha)
The boy's mental Craving will lead him to concoct further Full
Contact : to see Jordan play, to see one of his advertisements,
to go by Foot Locker again and again to look and touch those shoes
(Sense Craving). This increased physical contact along with the
initial mental identifications further lead the young boy to wish
to own the shoes himself in order to have that power in constant
possession. Further, he may begin to play more and work harder
on his game to get that much closer to experiencing that power
(Craving for Being). This latter form of Craving for Being can
actually lead to wholesome development where the boy seeks to
bring the power out in himself as opposed to just buying the shoes
or grasping at empty images. Practice and diligence to develop
his own power can turn into a wholesome long term goal (chanda-wise
want) if nurtured correctly with the right amounts of Not-self
added in.
Yet amongst some of these positive cravings, the young man also
experiences a lot of Craving for Non-Being. Building in his increasingly
competitive mind is a hierarchy of positives and negatives. That
which is below the status of what he aspires to gets lumped into
a world to be avoided and shunned. Inferior shoes, teams, basketball
camps and people and places which are an anathema to his dream
status may not only be looked down upon but harassed. As the boy's
star rises so may his arrogance and contempt for teachers, students
and even relatives who share different values and do not regard
him as a celebrity. After an initial hardening of identity around
clung to forms, the boy's identity is becoming more fluid as the
contents of his imagination and of consumer basketball culture
become blurred with daily reality. The distance and enormity of
his dream creates such an intense lack that the "self"
begins to destroy this gap between real and ideal. Before he is
there, the boy has already arrived and carries himself as the
"second coming" of Michael Jordan.
If these emotional dislocations are not enough, the grooming system
for producing NBA bodies will only add to this separation from
others. From junior high school, the recruiting, the summer camps
and leagues, the tryouts and the myriad levels of play condition
a constant personal evaluation, comparing and competing among
all kids his age. The incredible alienations that are created
in this system produce the insular, modern NBA star who is often
extremely private, duly paranoid, and incredibly close with either
family or an old group of friends.
CLINGING (upadana)
This type of Clinging that is conditioned by the Craving will
then lead on to actions.
1) On the level of Sense Clinging, the young boy becomes infatuated
with all material forms and images associated with Jordan, his
team the Bulls, and the NBA in general. Such an infatuation might
seem harmless on a certain level, yet when you reflect on the
amount of merchandise marketed and sold by Official NBA licensing
(not to mention the unofficial market), the Sense Clinging surrounding
basketball stars is big business.6
2) The next level of Clinging in the young boy's attitudes may
manifest itself in seemingly harmless posturing about Jordan and
the Bulls being the best or even Nike making the best products.
Yet attitudes of greater concern might become the belief that
acquiring the shoes and such related apparel will actually make
him a more powerful person. He says he feels more confident playing,
and he'll look more attractive to the girls. The speed
with which new types of apparel are developed and the power of
their imagery, which is reinforced by the depravity of his environment,
may begin to distract the young boy from the real issue at hand:
in order to make it to the NBA, he must somehow overcome his poor
schooling through diligent work and also improve the actual content
of his abilities while staying clear of the pitfalls of being
a young growing boy in a ghetto environment (teenage pregnancy,
drugs, and violence):
Which makes this process of playing for a scholarship not the black version of the American dream, as I had thought eight months earlier, but a cruel parody of it. In the classic parable, you begin with nothing and slowly accrue your riches through hard work in a system designed to help those who help themselves. Here, at seventeen years of age, you begin with nothing but one narrow, treacherous path and then run the gauntlet of obstacles that merely reminds you of how little you have: recruiters pass themselves off as father figures, standardized tests humiliate you and reveal the wretchedness of your education, the promise of lucrative NBA contracts reminds you of what it feels like to have nothing in this world.7
Getting lost in the allure of
material goods and the "image" associated with the NBA
can only complicate an already treacherous path.
3) This Clinging to attitudes will further concoct itself in Behavioral
Clinging. With so much Craving and Clinging built up and so few
ways to realize them, the boy is beginning to enter treacherous
waters. There is Clinging to the dream which, as we noted, in
many ways can be a positive thing. A long term goal that requires
self-discipline and personal development can lead to more positive
kinds of desires and goals (chanda) and a way out of, if
not Clinging, at least the depravity of his environment. Yet the
consumer dream is doing a good job of muddling the larger picture.
The young boy is very susceptible to the sensual aspects of this
dream. The images and symbols of the consumer world perpetuate
this. How will he get the shoes and apparel needed to create the
proper image? Perhaps a part time job, but in his environment,
jobs are scarce. Some boys get their money from drug dealers who
were former players as an investment in the dream.8 Such associations
can be dangerous pitfalls when a boy's grades or play begins to
drop him out of the ever narrowing circle of players who can at
least make it out of the neighborhood on a basketball scholarship
to a university in the "outside world". If and/or when
the dream fades, the behavior of selling drugs leaves him cash
to at least keep a hold of the empty images of power in the material
goods.
More disturbingly, though, is the way that the behavior of the
whole system is loaded against those with sincere desire and self-discipline.
This comes to fore in the need for the young boy to balance his
athletic development and his educational development. These are
both methods for realizing his dream. Although the basketball
system puts up a vain image of scholastic advancement as equal
to athletic advancement, the following numbers show what's in
store for him: less than 1% of 500,000 high school players in
the United States get Division I scholarships per year9, of this
1% only 44% end up graduating with degrees10, which means approximately
.044% or 220 boys nationwide follow the hoops dream to a university
degree; meanwhile approximately .010% or 50 boys nationwide make
an NBA team and even less as a career that spans more than two
or three years. Finally, as a microcosm of our global economy,
the gap between the mega rich and the merely well to do is increasing.
As contracts skyrocket towards $20 million dollars per year for
the hand full of mega stars (about 50 in a league of 324 players),
the rest of the players are tendered with minimum wage NBA salaries
($272,500) making the chances of making big money even smaller.
This is where the real tragedy of the "Hoop Dream" takes
place. Through the consumptive allure of the images of professional
athletes and the structures which feed on them as cash cows, millions
of student athletes Cling to the athlete part of their development.
Yet the percentage of high school basketball players who go on
to get a scholarship and a university degree much less make it
to the NBA and the big money is infinitesimally small. The failure
of public schools amidst great wealth in the United States and
the interest of universities to make money off of big time sports
rather than nurture those who have gotten the short end of the
stick in their educational development indicate how misplaced
priorities are in consumer societies. This form of Behavioral
Clinging is a true loss of value. For the individual, it is the
loss in value of an education for the illusory images of becoming
a well paid professional athlete. For society, it is the loss
in value of developing its own citizens for the pleasures of dispersion,
fame and entertainment. The competitive system may rightly challenge
us to be the best we can, but it also leaves those with no other
means all the way in the gutter. Meanwhile, the corporations (NBA,
apparel companies), universities, agents, coaches and all sorts
of other people make money off the casino gamble of a boy's life,
and Michael Jordan does advertisements for Nike saying "Stay
in School" yet himself bypassed his final year of college.11
4) The final form of Clinging to "self" is a build up
of the previous three forms of Clinging. The destructiveness of
this clinging is that the young man who gains a modicum of success
will lose perspective on real priorities and pitfalls due to his
built up sense of "self". Successful at a certain level
and told of his unlimited potential (the "next Jordan"),
the boy can get lost in his own image and forget the discipline
and focus which made him the success he has been. This clinging
to "self" creates manifest problems when it runs into
Aging & Dying which every ballplayer, even Jordan, must face,
the end of his career. The image of himself as a great player
is supported very much by the free apparel he receives, the special
camps he can go to, and the newspaper flashes of his dunks. Yet
if he becomes increasingly dependent on this image and identity,
he may soon lose his way from what really made him great.
MATURATION OF THE "SELF"
EXISTENCE (bhava)
BIRTH (jati)
From these various forms of Clinging, the project of the powerful, successful (but not yet) wealthy athlete "self" is manifesting. Action built of Craving and Clinging concocts more deeply into patterns of behavior in Bhava. His clinging to the consumer forms of products surrounding Michael Jordan and the NBA takes form in action. He develops obsessions with his appearance: one pair of Nike's for playground games, one pair for hanging out, and his best pair for games; the black Nike warm-up with one leg stylishly pulled up for going out with the guys, a nice Reebok one for dates; a new cool "walk" for his new game, and of course a portfolio of stylish slam dunks for attracting the girls, the recruiters and the media. The opportunities to receive free apparel and goods from prestigious camps, coaches and underground agents reinforce the young boy's "self" enslaved to sense forms.
However, as the pyramid competitive system of consumerism always
expresses itself, the free receiving of goods is only for the
elite few who make it to the best teams and summer camps. For
those on the middle and bottom layers still trying to develop
themselves or waiting for that growth spurt, inferior (non-Nike
or Reebok) or no goods are available. These boys are more liable
to come into contact with the drug dealers who may offer them
cash for their Cravings. The connection may develop into nothing,
but it also may be the first foot in the coffin for a marginal
player unlikely to succeed and tempted by the financial possibilities
of drug dealing. Again, there is the vanishing safety net for
those at the bottom of the American economy. Like players on a
losing team, they are merely the bottom for which the elite can
measure themselves. Without them there is no context for claiming
success.
The consumer images which the boy clings to and the consumer profits
which all those who surround him cling to push the boy into developing
his athletic prowess at the cost of academic and emotional development.
As we saw on the level of behavior, alienation from true meaning
is brought into action, just as Buddhadasa warned. Athletics begins
as a vehicle for realizing personal development, self-discipline,
self-sacrifice and a knowledge of the value of hard work to attain
any goal. However, at this point, athletics is becoming an end
in itself. It is no longer helping the boy to mature but is rather
becoming his prison. Athletics is taking precedence over all other
factors in his life. His after school time for homework is spent
at games, sleeping after exhausting practices, studying film or
watching another game, etc. His vacations are spent in practice
and at out of state tournaments. He is living, breathing and sleeping
athletics to the detriment of his own personal development. This
pattern in competitive sports is perhaps seen most acutely in
the development of young tennis players and gymnasts.
An ego is being nurtured and conceived which is susceptible to
the consumer forms, images and styles of competitive sports, and
more importantly, has difficulty dealing in situations apart from
this world, such as academics, certain social situations, etc.
In the athletic world, the boy's "self" is at home,
comfortable with the sensual forms, the views and attitudes, the
methods and institutions, and his own image of success and power.
Yet thrown into the classroom or into a non-competitive social
situation, the boy may suddenly be in crisis. Intimidated by the
new setting (which can be equally as competitive in academics)
and his small sense of "self" in the classroom, the
boy my suffer more from lack of "self" confidence than
lack of ability.
The above scenario for the competitive athlete cannot be seen
as a blanket one. There are the well-fanfared scholar athletes
who excel both in the classroom and on the court. Yet as we have
noticed in the pyramid system of competition, those who begin
at the higher level generally have more means to develop without
disaster. A boy from a middle upper class family may have pressure
to excel, yet if he fails, his schooling and environment will
have been adequate enough to make the transition to other forms
of endeavor. Certainly, boys and girls who have been successful
competitive athletes make great competitive business people. Yet
for those at the lower tiers, the professional dream is perhaps
their only hope. If they fail, their schooling will ensure them
they tumble back to where they came from. Having been milked for
all the capital they are worth, they will be thrown on the garbage
pile of American ghetto manhood.
These are the environments and life situations concocted in the
Maturation of the "Self". The shoe and apparel stores,
the advertising, and the media entice the boy's Sensual Craving.
His teammates, coaches, family, and agents convince him of his
ideas to go all the way to the NBA. The teams, the summer camps,
the universities, the boosters and agents, and the product marketeers
(like Nike which financially support all of these institutions)
create the structures in which he will be groomed, developed,
commodified, and sold. When we entered this action level of Craving
and Clinging, we began to see the emergence of structural defilement
(kilesa) around the boy. Here at his birth as a successful
and powerful (but not yet rich, only those in the NBA get the
real money) competitive athlete, we are also beginning to view
the whole gigantic social "self" born of the delusion
of competitive and consumerist society.
IMAGE: Nike Air Jordans $175, first pair bought at 14, freshman
in high school, half from money saved up from a summer job, half
as a present from mom. The age of innocence is over. The boy now
has a fully matured athlete "self" living in an extremely
complex structural "self" of competitive sports. He
not only has to contend with this grasping and self-serving internal
"self" but also has to deal with the structural predators
which seek to take advantage of this "self". As the
boy comes in contact with Aging & Dying, he will begin to
experience the real frustrations, complications and limitations
of this concocted "self".
AGING & DYING (jaramarana)
Athletics has a positive point in that it is clear that there
will have to be somewhere a natural death of the "self",
when even after a great NBA career, a player has to step out of
the limelight and accept the end. Some players don't go easily
into the night but all must have to. For the young boy, the farther
he gets into the dream the more the reality of it bites at the
Ignorance of that first day when Michael Jordan's whole life seemed
like one parade. The farther he goes, the higher the price he
has to pay in emotional suffering. It's our hope that someone
will appear to guide him to what is truly essential and steer
him clear of the material illusions of which the course is chocked
full.
One way he will encounter Aging & Dying, though not likely
understand it, is in the transience of sensual forms (Impermanence).
Within a week, his new Air Jordans have a smudge on them. Further,
the corporations only exacerbate his frustration by developing
new lines of Air Jordans and new products all the time. The experience
of death in the out-dating of goods by updating styles is a way
that consumer culture concocts boredom. For the unmindful absorbed
in fashion, this merely spins them on again in the pursuit of
the new. In competitive sports, this has recently gotten out of
control as teams are changing their logos and team colors every
few years. This immediately makes the old ones out of date and
makes their fans go out and buy all the goods and apparel they
have again with the new design. Teams like the New York Yankees,
Boston Celtics and Indianapolis Colts who have not changed their
original team designs are rare exceptions.
Another level of breakdown occurs when the boy begins to lose
control over his attaining and maintaining of states of Clinging.
The dream has always been fragile, but at least by taking care
of business on the court, the rest of the things he wanted and
needed would be taken care of (his shoes and apparel, his image
as a star, his poor grades forgotten, etc.). An injury or an inability
to meet his potential or to produce at the next level of competition
means that all these things will begin to disappear including
the many so called friends who had supported his image of "self".
The dream is still far away and the odds with his environment
are discouraging. This spills into fear that he will never have
the means to get the shoes, improve and gain that power that is
so awesome yet so far away. There is the constant fear that he
will never make it out of his neighborhood and end up "dead
or in jail like everybody else"12.Without the strength of
his own will or the help of a caring person close by, the young
boy will begin to panic in the water. He will more maniacally
cling to these things which make up the "self" but which
are not the real reasons for his success. The goods and apparel,
the "friends and fans", and the four year universities
will drift away, and this will create strong feelings of depression.
Unless the boy can make a major attitude adjustment, the downward
spiral back to the ghetto is imminent.
Still another aspect of Aging & Dying is Ignorance of the
way things are which often conditions fear and superstitious grasping.
He may begin to abuse the privileges he was awarded before in
a vain attempt to declare his old status. His grades may drop
even further, and he may begin to lash out at his environment
in anger or at himself through drug abuse. His denial of the death
of his dream and the image of his "self" is an Ignorance
of the way things are.
From the development of a "self" nurtured on Clinging
to consumer athletic sensual forms and to competitive sports as
an overarching value system and way of dealing with the world,
the boy stays in the ghetto with few skills and heavy defilements.
In losing the value of education and other social skills to the
higher good of sports, he is even more destitute in terms of ability
to get a job. Yet he has literally "bought" into the
American dream by cultivating a Clinging to consumer goods. Unfortunately,
the American dream does not give refunds back to the losers. Hopefully,
the Clinging he developed can be re-funneled into something constructive
like Craving and Clinging to a new dream of basic employment and
a stable family. Yet the rip-off that he has been given is more
likely to manifest in total despair in his situation, susceptibility
to the drug world which is the biggest employer in the ghetto,
and great anger which could lead to criminal behavior.
CONCLUSION
All sports dreams come to an end. Ideally, they should end with
a trophy or two on the mantle piece, a few good wins and a few
bad losses and some lessons with which to move on in life. Unfortunately,
for American ghetto youth, competitive sports is often a cruel
trip to Las Vegas where everyone steals your money and leaves
you on the highway out to the desert. The dream is literally sold
through the commodification of the games and players. For a tiny
few, it is a reality. For the economic elite, it is a pleasurable
diversion. For the bottom of the pyramid, the diversion aspect
of sports is merely macabre theater because in their environment
it serves less as a diversion than a reminder of what they truly
do not have and of what they have so little chance of getting.
They can dream of heaven but the sinners who get out of hell are
few and far between. For the large mass of us in the middle, it
is a consumptive diversion which keeps the economic system going
while ironically sedating us from the very reasons for our daily
struggle for economic livelihood. Every year is another year of
financially getting by, but perhaps we wouldn't feel the pinch
so much if we stopped buying all those Nike goods and NBA apparel.
If we did so, however, the economy built on consumer spending
and leisure industries would crumble and plunge us into deeper
financial strains, so best to forget it all with another play-off
triple-header.
This is the catch 22 of attempting to transform our own lives
and our society as a whole. We have developed economies and societies
which mirror the selves we have constructed. Pulling the plug
on either leaves us staring down the abyss of Not-self and the
collapse of society as we know it. We desire a more peaceful,
less harried and superficial way of finding meaning in our lives,
yet when we begin to disengage we my find ourselves "feeling
alone" and empty without the material diversions we have
built our identities upon. Similarly, by taking a step away from
such a society as a whole, we feel the threat of losing the material
achievements we have worked so hard for over the last few hundred
years and of plunging back into the Dark Ages.
This is where we arrive at the Third Noble Truth, that there is
indeed an answer to our problems and a concrete method to realize
this answer. In order to take steps forward in our personal lives
towards ending our sickness and then towards making intelligent
and practical steps towards changing our societies, we must begin
with the work of our spirits. The Buddhist path toward a world
beyond consumerism and exploitative economy is one that guides
from the inside out. By creating a wholesome base for our beings,
we can then know the proper steps to take towards changing our
societies and planet. Buddhism will not give us structural plans
for this society that our scientistic spirits cry for, but it
will offer a guiding foundation of personal and interpersonal
relationship which will fill our efforts towards new structural
plans with the proper amount of science and humanity.
NOTES:
1 The $20 million that basketball star Michael Jordan reportedly
received in 1992 for promoting Nike shoes exceeds the entire annual
payroll for the Indonesian factories that made them from female
workers making as little as 15 cents/hour. Korten, David C., When
Corporations Rule the World (West Hartford, Connecticut &
San Francisco: Kumarin Press, Inc. & Berrett-Koehler Publishers,
Inc., 1995), 111 AND Richard J. Barnett and John Cavanaugh, Global
Dreams: Imperial Corporations and the New World Order (New
York: Simon and Schuster, 1994) 325-29.
2 In the widely acclaimed documentary film "Hoop Dreams",
the issues of consumerism and the role it plays in forging the
"Hoop Dream" (or Hoop Delusion) are not directly addressed
but most certainly visible to the discerning eye. For a view which
goes more into the economic and exploitative side of this issue
see Frey, Darcy The Last Shot : City Streets, Basketball Dreams
(New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1994).
3 Jordan himself did not come from the ghetto but rather a middle-lower
income family from a small seaside town (Wilmington, North Carolina).
4 Translation: "First, I'll get the shoes, then make the
high school team, then gain a scholarship to a 4 year university
with one of the best basketball teams like University of North
Carolina or University of Michigan. Then after playing just two
years, I'll enter the NBA draft and get chosen as one of the top
6 players (i.e. "a lottery pick") . After signing a
preliminary 3 year rookie contract, I'll sell myself on the free
agent market for a multi-year contract worth over $100 million
dollars." Note: Kevin Garnett plays for the NBA Minnesota
Timberwolves. After failing to attain the proper test scores to
go to a 4 year university (he actually did want to go), he entered
the NBA draft straight out of high school as "a lottery pick".
After two years, he signed a 6 year $126 million contract at the
age of 21.
5 Division I-A is the highest league of university sports competition
in the United States.
6 The NBA sold $3.09 billion worth of shirts, jerseys, caps and
other merchandise in 1996, and about this same amount the year
before. Sean Callebs, "NBA Goods Sales Flatten : League Turns
to New Products -- and Faces -- to Boost Merchandise Profits",
CNN Financial News, March 24, 1997.
7 Frey, The Last Shot, 227.
8 from the movie "Hoop Dreams".
9 Frey, The Last Shot , 226.
10 For the class entering 1989 with 6 years to graduate, 44% graduated
as compared to 57% for the total student body, 58% for student-athletes
in general, and 54% for football players. Statistics based from
Division I member institutions only (approx. 300 schools) and
only those student-athletes receiving athletics aid (i.e. those
getting scholarships). source National Collegiate Athletic Association
(NCAA).
11 Jordan finally earned his degree from the University of North
Carolina 3 years after leaving school.
12 from the movie "Hoop Dreams".
Jonathan Watts
Think Sangha Coordinator
Your response to this
article